Contested Spaces Between Courtly Ties and State Surveillance

Policing the Mevlevî Lodges During the Hamidian Era (1876–1909)

Authors

  • Arzu Eylül Yalçinkaya Uskudar Universtiy

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.47979/aror.j.94.2.291-319

Keywords:

Hamidian surveillance, Yenikapı Mevlevîhâne, Mevlevî lodges, state–tekke relations, late Ottoman Istanbul

Abstract

This article offers a case study of the Yenikap? Mevlevîhâne in Istanbul during the Hamidian era (1876–1909), when the expansion of central authority and routine intelligence gathering reshaped the conditions of urban religious life. In this setting, Mevlevî lodges were embedded in elite sociability, literary and musical culture, and informal circuits of counsel, while also attracting suspicion as spaces that could sustain autonomous influence. Recent scholarship on late Ottoman Sufism has clarified the state’s institutional reach and the changing place of Sufi lodges within projects of regulation and reform. However, individual lodges often appear in this literature as backdrops to larger political narratives. The Yenikap? Mevlevîhâne, an âsitâne (main lodge) with
dense documentation and a long record of courtly connections, affords a more closely textured account of how surveillance operated on the ground and how a lodge managed its public standing under conditions of rumour and scrutiny. The article draws on Ottoman state archives, contemporary narratives, and historical records such as ?htifalci Mehmed Ziya’s Yenikap? Mevlevihânesi (1913), authored by a direct observer of the lodge’s activities during the era, the Defter-i Dervi?ân, a compendium of historical and biographical records maintained by the lodge’s sheikhs, and the memoirs of Mevlevî affiliates. Read together, these sources trace a shift from earlier idioms of patronage and mutual recognition to a tighter regime of administrative oversight in the late 19th century. Following the tenures of Osman Selâhaddin Dede (d. 1887) and Mehmed Celâleddin Dede (d. 1908), the article argues that Yenikap?’s political significance lay less in overt opposition than in its capacity to host conversation and cultivate reputation and connection. In doing so, it reframes Hamidian surveillance not as an external pressure applied to static institutions, but as a condition that shaped the everyday negotiation of authority, legitimacy, and sociability within a major Mevlevî lodge.

Published

2026-10-12

Issue

Section

Research Article

How to Cite

Yalçinkaya, A. E. (2026). Contested Spaces Between Courtly Ties and State Surveillance: Policing the Mevlevî Lodges During the Hamidian Era (1876–1909). Archiv Orientální, 94(2), 291-319. https://doi.org/10.47979/aror.j.94.2.291-319